The right AI for your social selling is the one that writes your posts and messages best, so test both on your own content before you commit.

Consultants who sell through LinkedIn and other social platforms write a lot. Posts, comments, replies to direct messages, short follow-ups after a call. AI can take a big share of that drafting. The question is which tool to trust with it.

Online comparisons rarely help. They test coding, maths or trivia. None of that tells you which tool will write a post your buyers want to read. So run your own test, on your own work.

What social selling asks of an AI

Before you compare, be clear about the job. For social selling, a good AI tool needs to:

Both Claude and ChatGPT can do all of this when they’re set up well. They just tend to do it differently, and you’ll notice the difference faster on your own material than in any review.

A one-hour test you can run

Pick five real tasks from last month. A good mix:

  1. A post about a lesson from a recent project.
  2. A reply to a comment that disagrees with you.
  3. A first message to someone who viewed your profile.
  4. A follow-up to a prospect who went quiet.
  5. A short post announcing a workshop or free resource.

Give both tools the same background: a paragraph on who you serve, three of your own past posts and your banned words. Then give each the same five tasks.

Score each draft out of five on three things. Does it sound like you? How much editing would it need? Would a buyer reply to it? Add up the scores. The higher total is your answer for now.

For a wider comparison across research, writing, privacy and day-to-day consulting work, read this side-by-side look at Claude and ChatGPT for consultants.

What to watch for in the results

A few patterns are worth noting as you score:

The setup matters more than the logo

Here’s the honest part. Most of the gap between a good and a poor draft comes from setup, not from the brand of tool. A tool that knows your buyer, your opinions and your voice will beat a smarter tool working from a blank chat.

So once you’ve picked a winner, spend your effort on its setup. Store your background once, in a Project or custom instructions, so every post starts from it. Review the setup each quarter as your offer changes.

A simple rule to finish

Choose one tool and use it daily for a month. Switching back and forth means you never build the setup that makes either one good. If you choose Claude, the free Set Up Claude the Right Way course shows you how to build that setup properly.